AfterReview·Referee Key Decision Evaluation Platform·Official Verdicts vs. Fan Votes

Premier League Key Match Incidents

296 Season KMIs · 84.8% On-Field · 92.9% Post-VAR
← Matchweek 9 (MW9)/Liverpool vs Arsenal
Premier League · Matchweek 9 · Sun 1 Nov 2026, 16:30 GMT
Match KMI History
2026/27 Season
KMI History With Appointed Crew (2026/27)
REF + VAR
Liverpool
No prior 2026/27 KMIs
Arsenal
8 KMIs
1 err · 0 overturned
Appointed Officials Score
PL Avg: 84.8% Ref · 97.9% VAR
AM
Andy Madley
5 PL Matches · 13 Ref KMIs Audited
REF
92.3%
On-Field KMI
+7.5% vs PL
93.8%
Panel Consensus
61/65 votes
1
On-Field Errors
0× 0:5 · 1 split
0
Overruled by VAR
1 stood
SA
Stuart Attwell
6 PL Matches · 22 VAR KMIs Audited
VAR
95.5%
VAR KMI
-2.4% vs PL
90.9%
Panel Consensus
100/110 votes
1
VAR Errors
1 missed · 0 wrong
4.5%
Intervention Rate
1 overturned
Combined Crew Score
2026/27 combined record of appointed officials
REF + VAR
94.3%
Combined KMI %
33/35 correct
92%
Crew Consensus
161/175 votes
2
Uncorrected Errors
1 Ref · 1 VAR
Match KMI Summary
Post-VAR Final Outcomes
Verified Errors Benefiting (Post-VAR)
REF + VAR
Liverpool: 0Arsenal: 1
7
KMIs Audited
86%
On-Field OK
0
Overruled VAR
1
Post-VAR Err
KMI Flashpoints Selected for Voting (1)
Open Votes Page →
19:57Penalty not awarded
People's Vote: 0 votes
Challenge by Timber (ARS) on Isak (LIV)
Panel On-Field 1:4VAR 2:3
View Vote Breakdown →
All Official KMI Panel Decisions
7 Ref (6 OK) · 0 Asst. Ref
19:57 · Penalty not awarded (Referee)KMI FLASHPOINTPOST-VAR ERROR
On-Field 1:4VAR 2:3
Challenge by Timber (ARS) on Isak (LIV)

The panel felt that a penalty should have been awarded for a holding action by Timber on Isak, 4:1. One panellist considered the short-lived holding to lack clear impact on the ability of Isak to progress. The majority also felt that VAR should have intervened to recommend an on-field review, 3:2, on the basis that it was a clear and obvious error. Two panellists considered that the subjectivity in assessing impact meant this did not meet the high threshold for VAR intervention.

19:57 · DOGSO Dismissal not given (Referee)
On-Field 5:0VAR 5:0
Challenge by Timber (ARS) on Isak (LIV)

The panel unanimously felt that there was no DOGSO offence.

28:21 · Penalty not awarded (Referee)
On-Field 5:0VAR 5:0
Challenge by Timber (ARS) on MacAllister (LIV)

The referee's call of no penalty for a challenge by Timber on MacAllister was supported.

28:35 · Penalty not awarded (Referee)
On-Field 5:0VAR 5:0
Challenge by Tzolis (ARS) on Gakpo (LIV)

The referee's call of no penalty for a challenge by Tzolis on Gakpo was supported with the contact deemed below the threshold for a foul.

34:06 · Penalty not awarded (Referee)
On-Field 5:0VAR 5:0
Handball appeal against Timber (ARS)

The penalty appeal for a potential handball offence against Tiimber was supported with the ball striking his supporting arm.

78:12 · Second Caution Dismissal not given (Referee)
On-Field 5:0VAR 5:0
Actions of Madueke (ARS) on MacAllister (LIV)

The panel unanimously felt that the referee's call of no second caution for the actions of Madueke was correct.

78:12 · Sending off dismissal not given (Referee)
On-Field 5:0VAR 5:0
Actions of Madueke (ARS) on MacAllister (LIV)

As above, the panel unanimously felt that the referee was correct not to issue a straight red card for the same incident as contact was negligible and the reaction of the opponent was clearly exaggerated.