AfterReview·Referee Key Decision Evaluation Platform·Official Verdicts vs. Fan Votes

Premier League Key Match Incidents

296 Season KMIs · 84.8% On-Field · 92.9% Post-VAR

2026/27 Premier League Referee & VAR Rankings

Pure KMI accuracy, 5-member Panel Consensus % (exact vote share), and Overruled by VAR metrics joined across MW1–MW10. Click any official to open their full KMI profile.

Min KMIs
RankOfficialCombined KMI %Panel ConsensusCorrect / KMIsErrors StoodOverruled by VARMatches
1
AH
Adam Herczeg
Referee
100%
100%
15/15 votes
3 / 30
0
0 ref · 0 var
2
2
JS
Josh Smith
Referee
100%
100%
5/5 votes
1 / 10
0
0 ref · 0 var
1
3
DE
Darren England
Referee & VAR
100%
98.9%
178/180 votes
36 / 360
4
0 ref · 4 var
13
4
PH
Paul Howard
VAR
100%
98.3%
113/115 votes
23 / 230
2
0 ref · 2 var
8
5
NH
Nicholas Hopton
VAR
100%
98.3%
59/60 votes
12 / 120
2
0 ref · 2 var
6
6
PT
Paul Tierney
Referee & VAR
100%
97.5%
78/80 votes
16 / 160
1
0 ref · 1 var
10
7
CH
Constantine Hatzidakis
VAR
100%
95.6%
43/45 votes
9 / 90
1
0 ref · 1 var
3
8
AK
Andrew Kitchen
VAR
100%
95%
38/40 votes
8 / 80
3
0 ref · 3 var
4
9
RJ
Robert Jones
Referee
100%
92.3%
60/65 votes
13 / 130
0
0 ref · 0 var
6
10
LS
Lewis Smith
Referee
100%
86.7%
13/15 votes
3 / 30
0
0 ref · 0 var
1
11
CP
Craig Pawson
Referee & VAR
96%
95.2%
119/125 votes
24 / 250
1
1 ref · 0 var
10
12
TW
Timothy Wood
VAR
96%
94.4%
118/125 votes
24 / 251
2
0 ref · 2 var
7
13
JB
James Bell
VAR
95.7%
94.8%
109/115 votes
22 / 231
4
0 ref · 4 var
6
14
MS
Michael Salisbury
Referee & VAR
94.4%
91.1%
82/90 votes
17 / 180
2
1 ref · 1 var
9
15
MD
Matt Donohue
VAR
94.1%
91.8%
78/85 votes
16 / 171
2
0 ref · 2 var
5
16
JB
John Brooks
Referee & VAR
93.8%
90%
216/240 votes
45 / 481
4
2 ref · 2 var
15
17
AM
Andy Madley
Referee
92.3%
93.8%
61/65 votes
12 / 131
0
0 ref · 0 var
5
18
ND
Neil Davies
VAR
90.9%
83.6%
46/55 votes
10 / 111
1
0 ref · 1 var
4
19
TB
Thomas Bramall
Referee
90%
90%
45/50 votes
9 / 100
1
1 ref · 0 var
5
20
SA
Stuart Attwell
Referee & VAR
90%
89%
178/200 votes
36 / 403
2
1 ref · 1 var
12
21
TH
Tony Harrington
Referee & VAR
89.5%
86.3%
82/95 votes
17 / 192
0
0 ref · 0 var
10
22
CK
Chris Kavanagh
Referee
88.9%
91.1%
82/90 votes
16 / 182
0
0 ref · 0 var
7
23
MO
Michael Oliver
Referee & VAR
88%
88%
110/125 votes
22 / 251
3
2 ref · 1 var
12
24
JG
Jarred Gillett
Referee & VAR
86.8%
85.8%
163/190 votes
33 / 383
3
2 ref · 1 var
13
25
TK
Thomas Kirk
Referee
83.3%
80%
24/30 votes
5 / 61
0
0 ref · 0 var
1
26
PB
Peter Bankes
Referee & VAR
82.4%
83.5%
142/170 votes
28 / 344
3
2 ref · 1 var
12
27
SB
Samuel Barrott
Referee
75%
80%
32/40 votes
6 / 81
1
1 ref · 0 var
7
28
FH
Farai Hallam
Referee
75%
75%
15/20 votes
3 / 40
1
1 ref · 0 var
4
29
SH
Simon Hooper
Referee
50%
66.7%
20/30 votes
3 / 62
1
1 ref · 0 var
2