AfterReview·Referee Key Decision Evaluation Platform·Official Verdicts vs. Fan Votes

Premier League Key Match Incidents

296 Season KMIs · 84.8% On-Field · 92.9% Post-VAR
AM

Andy Madley

Referee

2026/27 Premier League · MW1–MW10 · 5 appointments (5 On-Field · 0 VAR)

Combined KMI %
92.3%
12/13 correct
Consensus: 93.8% (61/65 votes)
On-Field Referee KMI
92.3%
+7.5% vs PL (84.8%)
12/13 OK · 0× 0:5 · 1 split err
VAR Official KMI
—
0 missed · 0 wrong overturns
Overruled by VAR vs. Stood
0overturned by VAR
0 on-field overturned · 0 correct VAR overturns
1 uncorrected error stood

Audited KMI Decisions (17)

Every official KMI across matches appointed as Referee or VAR Official (MW1–MW10).

MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: Referee19:57Penalty not awardedERROR STOOD
Challenge by Timber (ARS) on Isak (LIV)

The panel felt that a penalty should have been awarded for a holding action by Timber on Isak, 4:1. One panellist considered the short-lived holding to lack clear impact on the ability of Isak to progress. The majority also felt that VAR should have intervened to recommend an on-field review, 3:2, on the basis that it was a clear and obvious error. Two panellists considered that the subjectivity in assessing impact meant this did not meet the high threshold for VAR intervention.

On-Field 1:4
VAR 2:3
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: Referee19:57DOGSO Dismissal not given
Challenge by Timber (ARS) on Isak (LIV)

The panel unanimously felt that there was no DOGSO offence.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: Referee28:21Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Timber (ARS) on MacAllister (LIV)

The referee's call of no penalty for a challenge by Timber on MacAllister was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: Referee28:35Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Tzolis (ARS) on Gakpo (LIV)

The referee's call of no penalty for a challenge by Tzolis on Gakpo was supported with the contact deemed below the threshold for a foul.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: Referee34:06Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Timber (ARS)

The penalty appeal for a potential handball offence against Tiimber was supported with the ball striking his supporting arm.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: Referee78:12Sending off dismissal not given
Actions of Madueke (ARS) on MacAllister (LIV)

As above, the panel unanimously felt that the referee was correct not to issue a straight red card for the same incident as contact was negligible and the reaction of the opponent was clearly exaggerated.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: Referee78:12Second Caution Dismissal not given
Actions of Madueke (ARS) on MacAllister (LIV)

The panel unanimously felt that the referee's call of no second caution for the actions of Madueke was correct.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW7TOTTOT v COVCOVAppointed: Referee48.59Goal Awarded
Handball Appeal against Thomas-Asante (COV)

The on-field call of no handball offence before the goal was supported as the ball does not strike Thomas-Asante in the 'red zone'.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW7TOTTOT v COVCOVAppointed: Referee58.00Goal Awarded
Challenge by Marmoush (TOT) on Van Ewijk (COV)

The referee's call to award the goal was supported. Marmoush's movement is an expected footballing action and the contact does not meet the threshold for a foul.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW5BREBRE v CHECHEAppointed: Referee01:42Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Fofana (CHE) on Schade (BRE)

The referee's call of no penalty was supported, with the contact by Fofana below the threshold for a penalty.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW5BREBRE v CHECHEAppointed: Referee75:38Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Sangare (BRE) on Barco (CHE)

The on-field call of no penalty was supported with Sangare's action to block Barco's shot deemed to be an expected contact and below the threshold for a penalty.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW5BREBRE v CHECHEAppointed: Referee81:56Goal awarded
Schade (BRE) in an onside position

The on-field onside call to award the goal was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW5BREBRE v CHECHEAppointed: Referee90:00+03:52Goal awarded
Schade (BRE) in an onside position

The on-field onside call to award the goal was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4AVLAVL v NFONFOAppointed: Referee64:09Goal not awarded
Delap (NFO) in an offside position

The on-field offside decision to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Delap was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4AVLAVL v NFONFOAppointed: Referee78:04Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Lindelof (AVL)

The referee's call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against Lindelof was supported with his arms in an expected position.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4AVLAVL v NFONFOAppointed: Referee87:09Goal awarded
Aina (NFO) in an offside position - not interfering with opponent

The on-field call to award the goal was supported, with no offside offence against Aina before Jesus scored. Aina was judged to not have impacted the defender.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW2CRYCRY v MCIMCIAppointed: Referee05:59Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Strand Larsen (CRY)

The referee's call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against Strand Larsen was supported. The ball struck him on the thigh before deflecting onto his arm.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0