AfterReview·Referee Key Decision Evaluation Platform·Official Verdicts vs. Fan Votes

Premier League Key Match Incidents

296 Season KMIs · 84.8% On-Field · 92.9% Post-VAR
MW11 Flashpoints · Open Right After Full-Time

MW11 Flashpoints Open After Kick-Off

Only the 6–8 biggest flashpoints each Matchweek open for voting right after full-time. Cast your call on the left — once Wednesday's official PL KMI report drops, panel verdicts appear on the right and Rankings update.

MW11 Pre-Match Briefings →
MW10 · 8 flashpoints (Voting Closed)
MW10EVEEvertonvsCOVCoventryRef: Stuart Attwell
37:54Penalty·Referee
VOTING CLOSED · KMI PUBLISHED
On-Field: Penalty not awarded

Challenge by Tarkowski (EVE) on Yirenkyi (COV)

People's Vote
0 votes
0 pre-KMI votes recorded

Fan voting closed before MW10's official report was published.

Official KMI Panel5-Member Panel
On-Field
0:5 Incorrect
VAR
0:5 Incorrect

Tarkowski had a hold of Yirenkyi's hair as the Coventry attacker attempted to challenge for the ball. The panel unanimously felt that this was a punishable offence and that a penalty and a yellow card should have been awarded under the new guidelines for hair pulling actions this season. They also felt that VAR should have intervened, 0:5, as it was a clear and obvious error.

MW10ARSArsenalvsHULHullRef: Farai Hallam
41:02Penalty·Assistant Referee
VOTING CLOSED · KMI PUBLISHED
On-Field: Penalty not awarded

Havertz (ARS) in an offside position

People's Vote
0 votes
0 pre-KMI votes recorded

Fan voting closed before MW10's official report was published.

Official KMI Panel5-Member Panel
On-Field
0:5 Incorrect
VAR
0:5 Incorrect

Although Harvertz is clearly in an offside position, there is a clear and impactful holding action by Mendy before any potential offside offence by Havertz. Given the chronology of events, a penalty should have been awarded. The panel consdered the VAR intervention was correct; however, the outcome after the on-field review was considered to be incorrect as a penalty should have been awarded.

MW10EVEEvertonvsCOVCoventryRef: Stuart Attwell
60:24Goal·Referee
VOTING CLOSED · KMI PUBLISHED
On-Field: Goal awarded

Handball appeal against Barry (EVE)

People's Vote
0 votes
0 pre-KMI votes recorded

Fan voting closed before MW10's official report was published.

Official KMI Panel5-Member Panel
On-Field
2:3 Incorrect
VAR
5:0 Correct

This was a split decision, 2:3, with the majority feeling that on the balnce of probability the ball did accidentally strike Barry's hand before directly entering the goal. However, the non-VAR intervention was supported on the basis that the readily available footage did not provide conclusive evidence, which is the gateway for VAR intervention in factual matters.

96:15Red Card·Referee
VOTING CLOSED · KMI PUBLISHED
On-Field: Second caution dismissal not given

Actions of Tavernier (BOU)

People's Vote
0 votes
0 pre-KMI votes recorded

Fan voting closed before MW10's official report was published.

Official KMI Panel5-Member Panel
On-Field
2:3 Incorrect

There was a clear, deliberate action by Tavernier to delay the restart and the panel felt that a second caution should have been issued in this instance, 3:2.

71:01Penalty·Referee
VOTING CLOSED · KMI PUBLISHED
On-Field: Penalty Awarded

Challenge by Cook (BOU) on Ouattara (IPS)

People's Vote
0 votes
0 pre-KMI votes recorded

Fan voting closed before MW10's official report was published.

Official KMI Panel5-Member Panel
On-Field
1:4 Incorrect
VAR
4:1 Correct

The panel felt that Outarra made a clear step across Cook who didn't make a challenge and therefore, felt that the referee's decision to award a penalty was incorrect, 4:1. However, the non- VAR intervention was supported with it not being judged a clear and obvious error, also 4:1.

92:35Penalty·Referee
VOTING CLOSED · KMI PUBLISHED
On-Field: Penalty awarded

Challenge by Kerkez (LIV) on Osorio (CRY)

People's Vote
0 votes
0 pre-KMI votes recorded

Fan voting closed before MW10's official report was published.

Official KMI Panel5-Member Panel
On-Field
0:5 Incorrect
VAR
5:0 Correct

The panel unanimously felt that the referee's call of a penalty for a challenge by Kerkez on Osorio was incorrect with the contact being inevitable given the jumping actions of both players. However, the non-intervention of VAR was supported on the basis it was not a clear and obvious error.

20:30Red Card·Referee
VOTING CLOSED · KMI PUBLISHEDVAR Overturn
On-Field: Sending off, dismissal not given

Actions of Thiago (BRE) on Chema (BHA)

People's Vote
0 votes
0 pre-KMI votes recorded

Fan voting closed before MW10's official report was published.

Official KMI Panel5-Member Panel
On-Field
2:3 Incorrect
VAR
3:2 Correct

The VAR intervention leading to a red card outcome for Thiago was supported, 3:2. Thiago's forearm made forceful contact with the face of Chema. Two Panellists felt that the referee dealt with it adequately on field and that the referee's call was not a clear and obvious error.

MW10LEELeedsvsTOTSpursRef: John Brooks
33:06Red Card·Referee
VOTING CLOSED · KMI PUBLISHED
On-Field: Sending off dismissal not given

Challenge by Bogle (LDS) on Tel (TOT)

People's Vote
0 votes
0 pre-KMI votes recorded

Fan voting closed before MW10's official report was published.

Official KMI Panel5-Member Panel
On-Field
3:2 Correct
VAR
3:2 Correct

This was a split decision with the majority supporting the referee's on field call of no red card. The panel considered this to be a clear foul but the majority felt Bogle was looking to challenge with his right leg and his left leg came down on the back of Tel's ankle without the speed, force or intensity to be serious foul play. They felt that the contact made was very clearly reckless, but below the threshold for a red card. Two Panellists felt that the challenge was sufficiently dangerous to merit a red card. The non-VAR intervention was also supported, 3:2, on the basis that the majority considered the challenge to be reckless, therefore not a clear and obvious error.