AfterReview·Referee Key Decision Evaluation Platform·Official Verdicts vs. Fan Votes

Premier League Key Match Incidents

296 Season KMIs · 84.8% On-Field · 92.9% Post-VAR
← Referee Rankings/Stuart Attwell
SA

Stuart Attwell

RefereeVAR

2026/27 Premier League · MW1–MW10 · 12 appointments (6 On-Field · 6 VAR)

Combined KMI %
90%
36/40 correct
Consensus: 89% (178/200 votes)
On-Field Referee KMI
83.3%
-1.5% vs PL (84.8%)
15/18 OK · 1× 0:5 · 2 split err
VAR Official KMI
95.5%
-2.4% vs PL (97.9%)
1 missed · 0 wrong overturns
Overruled by VAR vs. Stood
2overturned by VAR
1 on-field overturned · 1 correct VAR overturns
3 uncorrected errors stood

Audited KMI Decisions (46)

Every official KMI across matches appointed as Referee or VAR Official (MW1–MW10).

MW10EVEEVE v COVCOVAppointed: Referee37:54Penalty not awardedERROR STOOD
Challenge by Tarkowski (EVE) on Yirenkyi (COV)

Tarkowski had a hold of Yirenkyi's hair as the Coventry attacker attempted to challenge for the ball. The panel unanimously felt that this was a punishable offence and that a penalty and a yellow card should have been awarded under the new guidelines for hair pulling actions this season. They also felt that VAR should have intervened, 0:5, as it was a clear and obvious error.

On-Field 0:5
VAR 0:5
MW10EVEEVE v COVCOVAppointed: Referee60:24Goal awardedERROR STOOD
Handball appeal against Barry (EVE)

This was a split decision, 2:3, with the majority feeling that on the balnce of probability the ball did accidentally strike Barry's hand before directly entering the goal. However, the non-VAR intervention was supported on the basis that the readily available footage did not provide conclusive evidence, which is the gateway for VAR intervention in factual matters.

On-Field 2:3
VAR 5:0
MW10BHABHA v BREBREAppointed: VAR20:30Sending off, dismissal not givenOVERRULED BY VAR
Actions of Thiago (BRE) on Chema (BHA)

The VAR intervention leading to a red card outcome for Thiago was supported, 3:2. Thiago's forearm made forceful contact with the face of Chema. Two Panellists felt that the referee dealt with it adequately on field and that the referee's call was not a clear and obvious error.

On-Field 2:3
VAR 3:2
MW10BHABHA v BREBREAppointed: VAR03:27Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Ajer (BRE) on Ayari (BHA)

The potential penalty for a challenge by Ajer on Ayari was supported as correct.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW10BHABHA v BREBREAppointed: VAR04:42Sending off, dismissal not given
Challenge by Ajer (BRE) on De Cuyper (BHA)

The on field call of no red card for Ajer stepping on the heel of De Cuyper was supported with the contact below the threshold for a sending off.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW10EVEEVE v COVCOVAppointed: Referee37:54Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Tarkowski (EVE)

The penalty appeal for a potential handball offence against Tarkowski was supported with his arm raised as part of his jumping motion in a justifiable position.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW10BHABHA v BREBREAppointed: VAR39:53Penalty awarded
Challenge by Lewis-Potter (BRE) on Vuskovic (BHA)

The referee's call to award a penalty for a holding offence by Lewis-Potter on Vuskovic was supported, 4:1. One Panellist felt that the contact was principally driven by the attacker and exaggerated, therefore below the threshold for penalising holding actions.

On-Field 4:1
VAR 5:0
MW10EVEEVE v COVCOVAppointed: Referee46:39Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Mykolenko (EVE) on Awoniyi (COV)

The referee's call of no penalty for a challenge by Mykolenko on Awonyi was supported on the basis that the contact, which they unanimously believed was a foul, occurred just outside the area.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW10EVEEVE v COVCOVAppointed: Referee51:21Goal awarded
Sakamoto (COV) in an onside position

The on-field onside call to award the goal was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW10EVEEVE v COVCOVAppointed: Referee53:43Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Armstrong (EVE)

The penalty appeal for a potential handball offence against Armstrong was supported, as his arm was in a justifiable position .

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW10EVEEVE v COVCOVAppointed: Referee80:21Goal awarded
Dewsbury Hall (EVE) in an onside position

The on-field onside call to award the goal was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW10BHABHA v BREBREAppointed: VAR86:23Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Kayode (BRE) on Rutter (BHA)

The referee's call of no penalty was supported with the contact judged to be below the threshold for a foul.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW10EVEEVE v COVCOVAppointed: Referee87:40Sending off dismissal not given
Challenge by Branthwaite (EVE) on Yirenkyi (COV)

The referee's call of no red card for a challenge by Branthwaite on Yirenkyi was supported as the contact was low and reckless rather than dangerous.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: VAR19:57Penalty not awardedERROR STOOD
Challenge by Timber (ARS) on Isak (LIV)

The panel felt that a penalty should have been awarded for a holding action by Timber on Isak, 4:1. One panellist considered the short-lived holding to lack clear impact on the ability of Isak to progress. The majority also felt that VAR should have intervened to recommend an on-field review, 3:2, on the basis that it was a clear and obvious error. Two panellists considered that the subjectivity in assessing impact meant this did not meet the high threshold for VAR intervention.

On-Field 1:4
VAR 2:3
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: VAR19:57DOGSO Dismissal not given
Challenge by Timber (ARS) on Isak (LIV)

The panel unanimously felt that there was no DOGSO offence.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: VAR28:21Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Timber (ARS) on MacAllister (LIV)

The referee's call of no penalty for a challenge by Timber on MacAllister was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: VAR28:35Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Tzolis (ARS) on Gakpo (LIV)

The referee's call of no penalty for a challenge by Tzolis on Gakpo was supported with the contact deemed below the threshold for a foul.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: VAR34:06Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Timber (ARS)

The penalty appeal for a potential handball offence against Tiimber was supported with the ball striking his supporting arm.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: VAR78:12Sending off dismissal not given
Actions of Madueke (ARS) on MacAllister (LIV)

As above, the panel unanimously felt that the referee was correct not to issue a straight red card for the same incident as contact was negligible and the reaction of the opponent was clearly exaggerated.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9LIVLIV v ARSARSAppointed: VAR78:12Second Caution Dismissal not given
Actions of Madueke (ARS) on MacAllister (LIV)

The panel unanimously felt that the referee's call of no second caution for the actions of Madueke was correct.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW8ARSARS v EVEEVEAppointed: VAR18:58Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Garner (EVE)

The on-field no handball decision was supported. The defender uses a supporting arm which is in a natural position given his actions.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW8SUNSUN v LEELEEAppointed: Referee66:10Sending off dismissal not given
Challenge by Bogle (LDS) on Mandava (SUN)

The on-field no red card decision was supported. Bogle's foot is high but there is little force or intensity in the contact.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW8ARSARS v EVEEVEAppointed: VAR67:58Goal awarded
White (ARS) in an onside position

The on-field onside call was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW8SUNSUN v LEELEEAppointed: Referee75:44Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Roefs (SUN) on Calvert-Lewin (LDS)

The on-field no penalty decision was supported. Roefs gets clear contact on the ball.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW8SUNSUN v LEELEEAppointed: Referee83:28Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Tanaka (LDS)

The on-field no handball call was supported as the ball is deflected towards Tanaka at speed.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW7NEWNEW v AVLAVLAppointed: VAR17:35Sending off dismissal not given
Challenge by Botman (NEW) on Jackson (AVL)

This was a split decision with the majority of the panel feeling that a red card for serious foul play should have been awarded, 4:1. Botman was out of control, lunging at speed, making forceful contact with Jackson despite his leading leg missing the Villa attacker. The non-VAR intervention was supported, 3:2, on the basis it was not a clear and obvious error.

On-Field 1:4
VAR 3:2
MW7NEWNEW v AVLAVLAppointed: VAR41:20Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Gonzalez (NEW) on Jackson (AVL)

The on-field call of no penalty was supported on the basis that Gonzalez possibly got a touch on the ball and the challenge may have occurred just outside the area.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW6MUNMUN v TOTTOTAppointed: Referee54:47Goal not awarded
Ball not kept in play by Cunha (MUN)

The decision to disallow the goal was supported, with the ball clearly out of play.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW6MUNMUN v TOTTOTAppointed: Referee76:33Sending Off dismissal not given
Actions of Shaw (MUN) on Bentancur (TOT)

The on-field no red card decision was supported, 4:1. Shaw's actions are aggressive but don't meet the threshold for violent conduct. One panellist felt that Shaw's push was with excessive force so deemed the on-field decision incorrect and would have supported a VAR intervention to recommend a red card.

On-Field 4:1
VAR 4:1
MW6MUNMUN v TOTTOTAppointed: Referee76:33Sending Off dismissal given
Actions of Bentancur (TOT) on Shaw (MUN)

The on-field red card decision was supported. The actions of Bentancur meet the threshold for violent conduct.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW5EVEEVE v IPSIPSAppointed: Referee57:19Goal awardedOVERRULED BY VARON-FIELD ERROR (VAR OVERTURNED)
Johnson (EVE) in an offside position - not interfering with opponent

The VAR intervention to disallow the goal for interfering with an opponent by Johnson was supported, 3:2. Johnson was clearly in an offside position, in very close proximity to the goalkeeper and makes a movement, impacting the goalkeeper's ability to set and move to the ball. Two panellists felt that Johnson's position and actions did not impact goalkeeper Walton.

On-Field 2:3
VAR 3:2
MW5EVEEVE v IPSIPSAppointed: Referee66:16Second caution dismissal given
Actions of Fatawu (IPS)

The panel supported the referee's decision to issue a second caution for simulation.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4SUNSUN v ARSARSAppointed: VAR53:28Penalty awarded
Challenge by Konsa (ARS) on Ballard (SUN)

The panel unanimously felt that the referee's call of a penalty for a holding offence was incorrect. Although it was a very untidy challenge in which Konsa initially had arms around Ballard, Ballard engages in a holding action which pulls Konsa onto him so they both fall to the floor. The non-VAR intervention was supported, 3:2, with the majority considering that the on-field decision was not a clear and obvious error, given the combined actions from both players.

On-Field 0:5
VAR 3:2
MW4SUNSUN v ARSARSAppointed: VAR33:40Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Brobbey (SUN) on Calafiori (ARS)

The referee's call of no penalty for a potential holding offence by Brobbey on Calafiori was supported, 4:1, with the contact made not reaching the threshold for a penalty kick.

On-Field 4:1
VAR 4:1
MW4SUNSUN v ARSARSAppointed: VAR75:44Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Tzolis (ARS) on Mukiele (SUN)

The referee's call of no penalty for a challenge by Tzolis on Mukiele was supported as correct with the contact below the threshold for a foul.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4SUNSUN v ARSARSAppointed: VAR77:18Goal not awarded
Timber (ARS) in an offside position

The on-field offside decision to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Timber was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4SUNSUN v ARSARSAppointed: VAR90:00+05:16Second caution dismissal given
Challenge by Mandava (SUN) on Saka (ARS)

The second caution dismissal for Reinildo was supported. As the foul was inside the penalty area, and whilst this was DOGSO, it was a genuine attempt to challenge for the ball, therefore punishable by a yellow card and not a direct red card.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4SUNSUN v ARSARSAppointed: VAR90:00+05:16Penalty awarded
Challenge by Mandava (SUN) on Saka (ARS)

The on-field award of a penalty was supported with an initial holding action by Reinildo followed by a genuine attempt to challenge for the ball - tripping Saka inside the penalty area.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW3BHABHA v LEELEEAppointed: Referee14:39Goal awarded
Calvert-Lewin (LDS) in an onside position

The on field onside decision to award the goal was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW3BHABHA v LEELEEAppointed: Referee36:18Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Justin (LDS)

The referee's call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against Justin was supported. The ball was played from close proximity and his arms were in an expected position.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW3BHABHA v LEELEEAppointed: Referee49:05Goal not awarded
Tanaka (LDS) in an offside position

The on field decision to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Tanaka was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW3BHABHA v LEELEEAppointed: Referee73:55Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Elvedi (LDS) on Yalcouye (BHA)

There was very little contact made on Yalcouye by Elvedi meaning this was below the threshold for penalising and the on field call of no penalty was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW2CRYCRY v MCIMCIAppointed: VAR05:59Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Strand Larsen (CRY)

The referee's call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against Strand Larsen was supported. The ball struck him on the thigh before deflecting onto his arm.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW1NEWNEW v LIVLIVAppointed: Referee23:40Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Jacquet (LIV) on Osula (NEW)

The Referee's call of no penalty was supported with Jacquet clearly playing the ball, with any contact being expected following a challenge.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW1NEWNEW v LIVLIVAppointed: Referee77:12Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Thiaw (NEW)

The Referee's call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against Thiaw was supported. His arms were in a justifiable position by his side.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW1NEWNEW v LIVLIVAppointed: Referee90:00+05:09Penalty awarded
Challenge by Hall (NEW) on Munoz (LIV)

The panel unanimously supported the Referee's call of a penalty. Hall stepped across Munoz making contact with the attacker and not with the ball.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0