AfterReview·Referee Key Decision Evaluation Platform·Official Verdicts vs. Fan Votes

Premier League Key Match Incidents

296 Season KMIs · 84.8% On-Field · 92.9% Post-VAR
Referee KMIs
+6 Asst. Ref (30 total)
24
On-Field Correct
Season avg: 84.8%
88%
On-Field Errors
3 unfixed final errors
4
VAR Errors
Season post-VAR: 92.9%
0

Matchweek 8 Matches & KMI Breakdown

Click any match for Pure-KMI Briefing & Panel Audit

Matchweek 8 Official KMI Panel Decisions

Click any row to read the official 5-member panel written commentary.

AVLvMCI
29:23Penalty not awardedPOST-VAR ERROR
Challenge by Anderson (MCI) on Manzambi (AVL) · Referee (Peter Bankes)
2 : 3
Incorrect
3 : 2
Correct
MCIMan City
▼
CHEvTOT
69:37Sending off dismissal not givenPOST-VAR ERROR
Actions of Palmer (CHE) on Fernandes (TOT) · Referee (Chris Kavanagh)
2 : 3
Incorrect
5 : 0
Correct
CHEChelsea
▼
CHEvTOT
84:26Penalty not awardedPOST-VAR ERROR
Challenge by Caicedo (CHE) on Solanke (TOT) · Referee (Chris Kavanagh)
2 : 3
Incorrect
3 : 2
Correct
CHEChelsea
▼
CRYvNEW
51:08Goal awardedOVERRULED BY VAR ✓
Willock (NEW) in an onside position · Assistant Referee (Paul Tierney)
0 : 5
Incorrect
5 : 0
Correct
CRYCrystal Palace
▼
HULvBRE
60:20Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Sangare (BRE) on Belloumi (HUL) · Referee (Robert Jones)
3 : 2
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
BREBrentford
▼
ARSvEVE
18:58Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Garner (EVE) · Referee (Tony Harrington)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
EVEEverton
▼
ARSvEVE
67:58Goal awarded
White (ARS) in an onside position · Assistant Referee (Tony Harrington)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
ARSArsenal
▼
AVLvMCI
18:22Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Gomes (AVL) on Fernandez (MCI) · Referee (Peter Bankes)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
AVLAston Villa
▼
AVLvMCI
30:25Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Maatsen (AVL) on Ndiaye (MCI) · Referee (Peter Bankes)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
AVLAston Villa
▼
AVLvMCI
73:22Sending off dismissal not given
Challenge by Anderson (MCI) on Gomes (AVL) · Referee (Peter Bankes)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
MCIMan City
▼
CHEvTOT
54:15Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Colwill (CHE) on van de Ven (TOT) · Referee (Chris Kavanagh)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
CHEChelsea
▼
CHEvTOT
76.20Goal awarded
Challenge by van Hecke (TOT) on Penders (CHE) · Referee (Chris Kavanagh)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
CHEChelsea
▼
CHEvTOT
79:31Second caution dismissal given
Challenge by Palmer (CHE) on Gallagher (TOT) · Referee (Chris Kavanagh)
4 : 1
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
TOTSpurs
▼
COVvFUL
45:00+00:42Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Thomas-Asante (COV) on Bassey (FUL) · Referee (Adam Herczeg)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
COVCoventry
▼
COVvFUL
90:00+01:30Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Charles (FUL) · Assistant Referee (Adam Herczeg)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
FULFulham
▼
CRYvNEW
17:38Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Schar (NEW) on Kamada (CRY) · Referee (Paul Tierney)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
NEWNewcastle
▼
HULvBRE
21:59Penalty awarded
Challenge by Hickey (BRE) on Iroegbunam (HUL) · Referee (Robert Jones)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
HULHull
▼
HULvBRE
31:36Penalty not awarded
Challenge by van den Berg (BRE) on Slater (HUL) · Referee (Robert Jones)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
BREBrentford
▼
IPSvNFO
12:11Goal awarded
Challenge by Gibbs-White (NFO) on O'Shea (IPS) · Assistant Referee (Thomas Bramall)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
NFONott'm Forest
▼
IPSvNFO
47:21DOGSO dismissal not given
Challenge by Diop (IPS) on McAtee (NFO) · Referee (Thomas Bramall)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
IPSIpswich
▼
LIVvBHA
61:33Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Mac Allister (LIV) · Referee (Samuel Barrott)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
LIVLiverpool
▼
LIVvBHA
82:04Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Jacquet (LIV) on Kostoulas (BHA) · Referee (Samuel Barrott)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
LIVLiverpool
▼
MUNvBOU
37:40Goal awarded
Hill (BOU) in an offside position - not interfering · Assistant Referee (Jarred Gillett)
4 : 1
Correct
4 : 1
Correct
BOUBournemouth
▼
MUNvBOU
45:22Goal not awarded
Evanilson (BOU) in an offside position · Assistant Referee (Jarred Gillett)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
MUNMan Utd
▼
MUNvBOU
45.00+00.25Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Silva (BOU) on Amad (MUN) · Referee (Jarred Gillett)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
BOUBournemouth
▼
MUNvBOU
59.17Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Adams (BOU) on Mbeumo (MUN) · Referee (Jarred Gillett)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
BOUBournemouth
▼
MUNvBOU
72:54Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Evanilson (BOU) · Referee (Jarred Gillett)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
BOUBournemouth
▼
SUNvLEE
66:10Sending off dismissal not given
Challenge by Bogle (LDS) on Mandava (SUN) · Referee (Stuart Attwell)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
LEELeeds
▼
SUNvLEE
75:44Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Roefs (SUN) on Calvert-Lewin (LDS) · Referee (Stuart Attwell)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
SUNSunderland
▼
SUNvLEE
83:28Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Tanaka (LDS) · Referee (Stuart Attwell)
5 : 0
Correct
5 : 0
Correct
LEELeeds
▼