AfterReview·Referee Key Decision Evaluation Platform·Official Verdicts vs. Fan Votes

Premier League Key Match Incidents

296 Season KMIs · 84.8% On-Field · 92.9% Post-VAR
TK

Thomas Kirk

Referee

2026/27 Premier League · MW1–MW10 · 1 appointments (1 On-Field · 0 VAR)

Combined KMI %
83.3%
5/6 correct
Consensus: 80% (24/30 votes)
On-Field Referee KMI
83.3%
-1.5% vs PL (84.8%)
5/6 OK · 0× 0:5 · 1 split err
VAR Official KMI
—
0 missed · 0 wrong overturns
Overruled by VAR vs. Stood
0overturned by VAR
0 on-field overturned · 0 correct VAR overturns
1 uncorrected error stood

Audited KMI Decisions (6)

Every official KMI across matches appointed as Referee or VAR Official (MW1–MW10).

MW9HULHUL v IPSIPSAppointed: Referee17:31Penalty not awardedERROR STOOD
Challenge by Mendy (HUL) on O'Shea (IPS)

This was a split decision, 4:1, with the majority feeling that there was a clear sustained holding offence by Mendy and a penalty should have been awarded. One panellist considered that the actions of O'Shea and Florentino should have been taken into account, meaning no penalty.

On-Field 1:4
VAR 1:4
MW9HULHUL v IPSIPSAppointed: Referee17:31Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Egan (HUL)

The no penalty decision for a potential handball offence against Egan was supported, 4:1.

On-Field 4:1
VAR 5:0
MW9HULHUL v IPSIPSAppointed: Referee20:19Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Mendy (HUL) on O'Shea (IPS)

The outcome of no penalty was supported by the panel. There is a clear and impactful holding action by O'Shea before the ball is in play from the corner kick, followed by a clear block by Florentino after the ball is in play, both prior to the holding action by Mendy. In this situation O'Shea commits an offence before the ball is in play, and Florentino makes a clear block when the ball is in play before the holding action by Mendy. As the holding action of Mendy meets the threshold for a clear and obvious error, a VAR intervention to recommend an on-field review should have occurred to allow the referee to consider all of the events in chronological order to reach the outcome of no penalty and a retaken corner.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9HULHUL v IPSIPSAppointed: Referee33:17Goal not awarded
Challenge by Fatawu (IPS) on McBurnie (HUL)

The panel supported the referee's on-field call to award a foul by Fatawu on McBurnie before the goal was scored.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9HULHUL v IPSIPSAppointed: Referee53:00Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Mendy (HUL) on Emersonn (IPS)

The panel supported the referee's call of no penalty on the basis that the contact from the challenge by Mendy was just outside the area, 4:1.

On-Field 4:1
VAR 4:1
MW9HULHUL v IPSIPSAppointed: Referee72:19Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Giles (HUL) on Daizen (IPS)

The referee's call of no penalty for a challenge by Giles on Maeda was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0