AfterReview·Referee Key Decision Evaluation Platform·Official Verdicts vs. Fan Votes

Premier League Key Match Incidents

296 Season KMIs · 84.8% On-Field · 92.9% Post-VAR
JB

John Brooks

RefereeVAR

2026/27 Premier League · MW1–MW10 · 15 appointments (7 On-Field · 8 VAR)

Combined KMI %
93.8%
45/48 correct
Consensus: 90% (216/240 votes)
On-Field Referee KMI
86.4%
+1.6% vs PL (84.8%)
19/22 OK · 3× 0:5 · 0 split err
VAR Official KMI
100%
+2.1% vs PL (97.9%)
0 missed · 0 wrong overturns
Overruled by VAR vs. Stood
4overturned by VAR
2 on-field overturned · 2 correct VAR overturns
1 uncorrected error stood

Audited KMI Decisions (54)

Every official KMI across matches appointed as Referee or VAR Official (MW1–MW10).

MW10LEELEE v TOTTOTAppointed: Referee03:42Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Fernandes (TOT)

The penalty appeal for a potential handball offence against Fernandes was supported as whilst he clearly leant into the path of the ball, the contact with the arm was in the "green zone" and therefore not punishable.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW10LEELEE v TOTTOTAppointed: Referee33:06Sending off dismissal not given
Challenge by Bogle (LDS) on Tel (TOT)

This was a split decision with the majority supporting the referee's on field call of no red card. The panel considered this to be a clear foul but the majority felt Bogle was looking to challenge with his right leg and his left leg came down on the back of Tel's ankle without the speed, force or intensity to be serious foul play. They felt that the contact made was very clearly reckless, but below the threshold for a red card. Two Panellists felt that the challenge was sufficiently dangerous to merit a red card. The non-VAR intervention was also supported, 3:2, on the basis that the majority considered the challenge to be reckless, therefore not a clear and obvious error.

On-Field 3:2
VAR 3:2
MW9MCIMCI v BHABHAAppointed: VAR08:18Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Gomez (BHA)

The no penalty decision for a potential handball offence against Ayari was supported with the ball deflecting off his teammate from close proximity.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9MCIMCI v BHABHAAppointed: VAR14:49Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Dunk (BHA)

The no penalty decision for a potential handball offence against Dunk was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9MCIMCI v BHABHAAppointed: VAR43:10Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Vuskovic (BHA)

The no penalty decision for a potential handball offence against Vuskovic was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9MCIMCI v BHABHAAppointed: VAR45:00+01:08Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Dunk (BHA)

The no penalty decision for a potential handball offence against Dunk was supported, 3:2. The ball struck Dunk on the thigh/arm before hitting his opposite arm, with his arms down by his side. Two panellists felt that Dunk had enough time to reposition his arms given the distance the ball travelled and considered this a punishable handball.

On-Field 3:2
VAR 3:2
MW9NEWNEW v EVEEVEAppointed: Referee48:22Goal awarded
Challenge by Barry (EVE) on Schar (NEW)

The panel supported the referee's call of no foul by Barry on Schar. Barry was ahead of the Newcastle defender and the contact was below the threshold for a foul.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9NEWNEW v EVEEVEAppointed: Referee48:22Goal awarded
Barry (EVE) in an onside position

The on-field onside decision to award the goal was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9NEWNEW v EVEEVEAppointed: Referee68:12Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Rohl (EVE) on Hall (NEW)

The referee's call of no penalty for a challenge by Rohl on Hall was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW9NEWNEW v EVEEVEAppointed: Referee90:00+07:13Second Caution Dismissal given
Challenge by Ramsey (NEW) on Armstrong (EVE)

The panel unanimously supported the referee's call of a second caution for Ramsey for a reckless challenge.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW8CHECHE v TOTTOTAppointed: VAR69:37Sending off dismissal not given
Actions of Palmer (CHE) on Fernandes (TOT)

The on-field no red card decision was deemed incorrect, 3:2. The majority felt that Palmer's action on Fernandes was clear contact to the head as well as unnecessary, dangerous and made with excessive force. Two panellists supported the on-field call as they viewed the action as aggressive with no excessive force. All panellists supported the VAR's decision to not intervene and support the referee's call given that a yellow card was awarded on-field.

On-Field 2:3
VAR 5:0
MW8CHECHE v TOTTOTAppointed: VAR84:26Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Caicedo (CHE) on Solanke (TOT)

The on-field no penalty call was deemed incorrect, 3:2. The majority felt Caicedo was persistently holding Solanke whilst facing away from the ball and impacting the ability of the opponent to progress. Two panellists supported the on-field call as they felt both players are engaging and Caicedo is twisting to look at the ball. The VAR decision to not intervene was supported, 3:2.

On-Field 2:3
VAR 3:2
MW8CHECHE v TOTTOTAppointed: VAR54:15Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Colwill (CHE) on van de Ven (TOT)

The on-field no penalty call was supported. The challenge made by Colwill does not warrant the exaggerated fall from van de Ven.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW8CHECHE v TOTTOTAppointed: VAR76.20Goal awarded
Challenge by van Hecke (TOT) on Penders (CHE)

The on-field decision to award the goal was supported. The contact from van Hecke doesn't impact the goalkeeper's challenge for the ball or meet the threshold for a foul.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW8CHECHE v TOTTOTAppointed: VAR79:31Second caution dismissal given
Challenge by Palmer (CHE) on Gallagher (TOT)

The on-field second yellow card decision was supported, 4:1. The challenge from Palmer is reckless and avoidable. One panellist deemed this incorrect for a careless foul rather than reckless but supported the VAR not intervening as this decision should remain referee's call.

On-Field 4:1
VAR 5:0
MW7BREBRE v LIVLIVAppointed: Referee40:06Penalty awardedOVERRULED BY VARON-FIELD ERROR (VAR OVERTURNED)
Challenge by Ouattara (BRE) on MacAllister (LIV)

The VAR intervention to overturn the on-field penalty decision was supported. Ouattara got a touch on the ball before making contact with the Liverpool attacker.

On-Field 0:5
VAR 5:0
MW7BREBRE v LIVLIVAppointed: Referee45:00+03:59Sending off dismissal not givenOVERRULED BY VARON-FIELD ERROR (VAR OVERTURNED)
Actions of Yarmolyuk (BRE) on Jacquet (LIV)

The VAR overturn to issue a red card for violent conduct against Yarmolyuk was unanimously supported with a clear movement of the head making contact with Jacquet.

On-Field 0:5
VAR 5:0
MW7BREBRE v LIVLIVAppointed: Referee37:55Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Yarmolyuk (BRE) on Wirtz (LIV)

The penalty appeal for a challenge by Yarmolyuk on Wirtz was supported as correct with the contact exaggerated by the attacker as the ball ran through to the goalkeeper.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW7BREBRE v LIVLIVAppointed: Referee80:58Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Jacquet (LIV) on Thiago (BRE)

Thiago instigated the first contact before mutual holding from both players, which was below the threshold for a penalty. The on-field call of no penalty was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW7BREBRE v LIVLIVAppointed: Referee90:00+00:53Second caution dismissal given
Challenge by Janelt (BRE) on Ngumoha (LIV)

The panel unanimously supported the referee's call to issue a second caution for stopping a promising attack.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW6CHECHE v BOUBOUAppointed: VAR02:29Goal awarded
Pedro (CHE) in an onside position

The on-field onside decision was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW6CHECHE v BOUBOUAppointed: VAR02:29Goal awarded
Rogers (CHE) in an onside position

The on-field onside decision was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW6COVCOV v NEWNEWAppointed: Referee03:51Penalty awarded
Challenge by Hornicek (NEW) on Cherif (COV)

The on-field penalty call was supported as the goalkeeper commits a clear foul.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW6COVCOV v NEWNEWAppointed: Referee31:35Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Rudoni (COV)

The no handball call against Rudoni was supported as his arm is within his body.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW6COVCOV v NEWNEWAppointed: Referee85:50Goal awarded
Thomas-Asante (COV) in an offside position - no line of Vision

The decision to award the goal was supported. Thomas-Asante is in an offside position but not in the goalkeeper's line of vision.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW5TOTTOT v AVLAVLAppointed: VAR59:18Goal awardedOVERRULED BY VAR
Robertson (TOT) in an onside position

The VAR intervention to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Robertson was supported.

On-Field 0:5
VAR 5:0
MW5TOTTOT v AVLAVLAppointed: VAR33:27Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Wan Bissaka (AVL)

The no penalty decision for a potential handball offence against Wan-Bissaka was supported on the basis that the ball hit in the green zone and was headed onto him from close proximity.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW5TOTTOT v AVLAVLAppointed: VAR85:46Goal awarded
Kudus (TOT) in an onside position

The on-field onside call to award the goal was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4SUNSUN v ARSARSAppointed: Referee53:28Penalty awardedERROR STOOD
Challenge by Konsa (ARS) on Ballard (SUN)

The panel unanimously felt that the referee's call of a penalty for a holding offence was incorrect. Although it was a very untidy challenge in which Konsa initially had arms around Ballard, Ballard engages in a holding action which pulls Konsa onto him so they both fall to the floor. The non-VAR intervention was supported, 3:2, with the majority considering that the on-field decision was not a clear and obvious error, given the combined actions from both players.

On-Field 0:5
VAR 3:2
MW4LEELEE v NEWNEWAppointed: VAR00:47Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Fernandez-Padro (NEW)

The referee's call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against Fernandez-Pardo was supported with his arms in an expected position given the bounce of the ball. There was no movement of the arm towards the ball.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4SUNSUN v ARSARSAppointed: Referee33:40Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Brobbey (SUN) on Calafiori (ARS)

The referee's call of no penalty for a potential holding offence by Brobbey on Calafiori was supported, 4:1, with the contact made not reaching the threshold for a penalty kick.

On-Field 4:1
VAR 4:1
MW4LEELEE v NEWNEWAppointed: VAR33:57Goal awarded
Bogle (LDS) in an onside position

The on-field onside call to award the goal was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4LEELEE v NEWNEWAppointed: VAR42:53Sending off dismissal not given
Actions of Calvert-Lewin (LDS) on Botman (NEW)

The referee's call of no red card for violent conduct against Calvert-Lewin was supported. Calvert- Lewin stood his ground and used his arms to protect the space. There was no movement of the arm towards Botman.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4LEELEE v NEWNEWAppointed: VAR63:58Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Muharemovic (LDS) on Barnes (NEW)

The referee's call of no penalty for a potential foul by Muharemovic on Barnes was supported, 4:1, with the contact not meeting the threshold for a foul.

On-Field 4:1
VAR 4:1
MW4SUNSUN v ARSARSAppointed: Referee75:44Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Tzolis (ARS) on Mukiele (SUN)

The referee's call of no penalty for a challenge by Tzolis on Mukiele was supported as correct with the contact below the threshold for a foul.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4SUNSUN v ARSARSAppointed: Referee77:18Goal not awarded
Timber (ARS) in an offside position

The on-field offside decision to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Timber was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4SUNSUN v ARSARSAppointed: Referee90:00+05:16Second caution dismissal given
Challenge by Mandava (SUN) on Saka (ARS)

The second caution dismissal for Reinildo was supported. As the foul was inside the penalty area, and whilst this was DOGSO, it was a genuine attempt to challenge for the ball, therefore punishable by a yellow card and not a direct red card.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW4SUNSUN v ARSARSAppointed: Referee90:00+05:16Penalty awarded
Challenge by Mandava (SUN) on Saka (ARS)

The on-field award of a penalty was supported with an initial holding action by Reinildo followed by a genuine attempt to challenge for the ball - tripping Saka inside the penalty area.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW3FULFUL v CRYCRYAppointed: VAR13:25Goal awardedOVERRULED BY VAR
Kamada (CRY) in an onside position

The VAR intervention to disallow the goal for an offside offence against Kamada was supported.

On-Field 0:5
VAR 5:0
MW3EVEEVE v MUNMUNAppointed: Referee34:28Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Johnson (EVE) on Martinez (MUN)

The referee's call of no penalty for a potential foul by Johnson was supported. The contact was deemed below the threshold for a penalty.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW3EVEEVE v MUNMUNAppointed: Referee60:56Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Tarkwoski (EVE) on Cunha (MUN)

The referee's call of no penalty was supported as Tarkowski clearly and fairly won the ball through Cunha's legs.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW3EVEEVE v MUNMUNAppointed: Referee87:10Goal awarded
Sesko (MUN) in an onside position

The on field onside decision to award the goal was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW2BOUBOU v EVEEVEAppointed: VAR17:07Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Tavernier (BOU) on Tarkowski (EVE)

The referee's call of no penalty was supported, with both players engaging in holding actions that are below the threshold for being penalised.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW2BOUBOU v EVEEVEAppointed: VAR54:09Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Hill (BOU) on Dewsbury-Hall (EVE)

The referee's call of no penalty was supported with this being deemed a collision between the two players rather than a foul.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW2BOUBOU v EVEEVEAppointed: VAR73:55Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Scott (BOU)

The referee's call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against Scott was supported as the arm was in a justifiable position.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW1BREBRE v TOTTOTAppointed: VAR03:10Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Gallagher (TOT)

The Referee's call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against Gallagher was supported. Gallagher's arm was in a justifiable position with the defender right in front of him.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW1FULFUL v CHECHEAppointed: Referee04:04DOGSO dismissal not given
Challenge by Colwill (CHE) on Bobb (FUL)

The Referee's call of a yellow card for a potential DOGSO was supported with the attacker playing the ball away from goal; so this was not considered an obvious goalscoring opportunity.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW1FULFUL v CHECHEAppointed: Referee11:14Sending off dismissal not given
Challenge by Lavia (CHE) on Bassey (FUL)

The challenge by Lavia on Bassey was judged to be low, reckless, and lacked the force and intensity for a red card. The Referee's call of a yellow card for a reckless challenge was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW1FULFUL v CHECHEAppointed: Referee18:52Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against Robinson (FUL)

The Referee's call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against Robinson was supported, 4:1. The ball comes off his head before making contact with his arm as he is stooping to clear. One panellist felt that the movement of Robinson's right arm was deliberate and a penalty should have been awarded.

On-Field 4:1
VAR 4:1
MW1BREBRE v TOTTOTAppointed: VAR46:56Penalty not awarded
Challenge by Senesi (TOT) on Collins (BRE)

The panel unanimously supported the Referee's call of no penalty, understanding that there is a slight pull on Collins' shirt, but judging that Collins had initially instigated the contact with Senesi before going to ground.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW1FULFUL v CHECHEAppointed: Referee48:33Goal awarded
Pedro (CHE) in an onside position

The on-field onside decision to award the goal was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW1BREBRE v TOTTOTAppointed: VAR52:45Penalty not awarded
Handball appeal against van Hecke (TOT)

The Referee's call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against van Hecke was supported. His arms were tucked in and the ball hits from close proximity.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW1BREBRE v TOTTOTAppointed: VAR52:49Penalty awarded
Challenge by Bentancur (TOT) on Schade (BRE)

The panel supported the Referee's call of a penalty for a foul by Bentancur. Contact was made into the back of Schade, reaching the threshold for a penalty kick.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0
MW1FULFUL v CHECHEAppointed: Referee89:56Goal not awarded
Quenda (CHE) in an offside position

The on-field offside decision to disallow the goal for an offence against Quenda was supported.

On-Field 5:0
VAR 5:0