AfterReview·Referee Key Decision Evaluation Platform·Official Verdicts vs. Fan Votes

Premier League Key Match Incidents

296 Season KMIs · 84.8% On-Field · 92.9% Post-VAR
← Matchweek 1 (MW1)/Brighton vs Aston Villa
Premier League · Matchweek 1 · Sun 23 Aug 2026, 14:00 BST
American Express Stadium·REFPeter BankesVARMatt Donohue
Match KMI History
2026/27 Season
KMI History With Appointed Crew (2026/27)
REF + VAR
Brighton
No prior 2026/27 KMIs
Aston Villa
8 KMIs
1 err · 1 overturned
Appointed Officials Score
PL Avg: 84.8% Ref · 97.9% VAR
PB
Peter Bankes
6 PL Matches · 19 Ref KMIs Audited
REF
68.4%
On-Field KMI
-16.4% vs PL
71.6%
Panel Consensus
68/95 votes
6
On-Field Errors
3× 0:5 · 3 split
2
Overruled by VAR
4 stood
MD
Matt Donohue
5 PL Matches · 17 VAR KMIs Audited
VAR
94.1%
VAR KMI
-3.8% vs PL
91.8%
Panel Consensus
78/85 votes
1
VAR Errors
0 missed · 1 wrong
17.6%
Intervention Rate
2 overturned
Combined Crew Score
2026/27 combined record of appointed officials
REF + VAR
80.6%
Combined KMI %
29/36 correct
81.1%
Crew Consensus
146/180 votes
5
Uncorrected Errors
4 Ref · 1 VAR
Match KMI Summary
Post-VAR Final Outcomes
Verified Errors Benefiting (Post-VAR)
REF + VAR
Brighton: 0Aston Villa: 1
6
KMIs Audited
67%
On-Field OK
1
Overruled VAR
1
Post-VAR Err
KMI Flashpoints Selected for Voting (2)
Open Votes Page →
78:53Penalty not awarded
People's Vote: 0 votes
Challenge by McGinn (AVL) on Osman (BHA)
Panel On-Field 1:4VAR 3:2
View Vote Breakdown →
37:20Sending off dismissal not given
People's Vote: 0 votes
Actions of Gomes (AVL) on Rutter (BHA)
Panel On-Field 0:5VAR 5:0
View Vote Breakdown →
All Official KMI Panel Decisions
4 Ref (2 OK) · 2 Asst. Ref
78:53 · Penalty not awarded (Referee)KMI FLASHPOINTPOST-VAR ERROR
On-Field 1:4VAR 3:2
Challenge by McGinn (AVL) on Osman (BHA)

The panel were split, 4:1, with the majority feeling that a penalty should have been awarded on- field. McGinn steps into challenge Osman and makes contact without playing the ball. Whilst the majority of the panel preferred the outcome to be a penalty, with the high threshold for VAR intervention, the majority, 3:2, felt that it was not a clear and obvious error.

37:20 · Sending off dismissal not given (Referee)KMI FLASHPOINTOVERRULED BY VAR
On-Field 0:5VAR 5:0
Actions of Gomes (AVL) on Rutter (BHA)

The VAR intervention to award a red card for violent conduct was unanimously supported. Gomes kicked out at Rutter after the ball had gone.

17:23 · Goal awarded (Assistant Referee)
On-Field 5:0VAR 5:0
Rutter (BHA) in an onside position

The on-field onside decision to award the goal was supported.

30:32 · Goal awarded (Referee)
On-Field 5:0VAR 5:0
Challenge by Ayari (BHA) on Gomes (AVL)

The panel felt that the challenge did not meet the high threshold for a foul, therefore, the Referee's call to award the goal was supported.

53:37 · Penalty not awarded (Referee)
On-Field 5:0VAR 5:0
Handball appeal against Torres (AVL)

The Referee's call of no penalty for a potential handball offence against Torres was supported. His arms were in an expected position when aerially challenging for the ball.

64:46 · Goal not awarded (Assistant Referee)
On-Field 5:0VAR 5:0
Kostoulas (BHA) in an offside position

The on-field offside decision to disallow the goal for an offence against Kostoulas was supported.